Main Details: Registry number App_44130/2024 Date 23 août, 2024 Parties Aiko Energy Germany GmbH, Solarlab Aiko Europe GmbH Order/Decision reference ORD_45883/2024 Type of action Generic application Language of Proceedings Allemand Court - Division Court of First Instance - Düsseldorf (DE) Local Division German Headnotes: 1. A submission, although lodged in English, shall be declared admissible if it was not returned by the Registry as provided for by the RoP, which does not envisage any other consequence in such situation. In accordance with R. 7.1 RoP, it is for the Court to decide on a case-by-case basis whether an application pursuant to R. 323 lodged in a different language is to be rejected. 2. When deciding on a request to change the language of the proceedings to the language in which the patent was granted, all relevant circumstances relating to the case and to the position of the parties must be taken into account. If the balance of interests is equal – such as when both parties are international companies with significant internal resources – the position of the defendant is the decisive factor. In contrast to the language skills of the representatives of the parties, the ability for the managing directors or their equivalents on both sides to understand the language of the proceedings is a relevant consideration. German Mots-clés: Change of the language of the proceedings Back to Decisions and Orders
Main Details: Registry number App_44130/2024 Date 23 août, 2024 Parties Aiko Energy Germany GmbH, Solarlab Aiko Europe GmbH Order/Decision reference ORD_45883/2024 Type of action Generic application Language of Proceedings Allemand Court - Division Court of First Instance - Düsseldorf (DE) Local Division German Headnotes: 1. A submission, although lodged in English, shall be declared admissible if it was not returned by the Registry as provided for by the RoP, which does not envisage any other consequence in such situation. In accordance with R. 7.1 RoP, it is for the Court to decide on a case-by-case basis whether an application pursuant to R. 323 lodged in a different language is to be rejected. 2. When deciding on a request to change the language of the proceedings to the language in which the patent was granted, all relevant circumstances relating to the case and to the position of the parties must be taken into account. If the balance of interests is equal – such as when both parties are international companies with significant internal resources – the position of the defendant is the decisive factor. In contrast to the language skills of the representatives of the parties, the ability for the managing directors or their equivalents on both sides to understand the language of the proceedings is a relevant consideration. German Mots-clés: Change of the language of the proceedings Back to Decisions and Orders